Solved Case — Convicted The Murder of Macy Grace Ditty...
View Full CaseSolved Case — Convicted
The Murder of Sydney Sutherland
● Case Closed
Murder — Rape — Kidnapping
Jackson County, Arkansas
August 19, 2020
01
Victim Profile
Sydney Sutherland
Sydney Sutherland
Victim, Age 25
Sydney Sutherland
Sydney Sutherland was 25 years old and a licensed practical nurse at Unity Health Harris Medical Center in Newport, Arkansas. She had grown up in Tuckerman, Arkansas, the same small town where Quake Lewellyn had also attended high school. Her family described her as a genuine spirit and a bright ray of sunshine who loved animals, exercising, shopping, and books. Pink was her favorite color; the courtroom at Lewellyn's sentencing was filled with supporters wearing pink in her memory.
Sydney jogged regularly in her rural community. On August 19, 2020, she left for a run at approximately 3 p.m. on County Road 41 near Newport. She did not return. She had recently unfriended Lewellyn on Facebook in the period before her death, according to the case affidavit. He had been married and living with his wife and three stepchildren at the time of the attack.
An Arkansas State University scholarship was created in her memory following her death. Her mother Maggy Sutherland spoke directly to Lewellyn at his sentencing and said: "She was not yours to take." Sydney Sutherland was a nurse who went out for a run and did not come home. She was 25 years old.
01
Overview
What We Know
On August 19, 2020, Sydney Sutherland left for a jog at approximately 3 p.m. on County Road 41 near Newport, Arkansas. She did not return. Her family reported her missing and law enforcement began searching the area. Sydney and Quake Lewellyn had attended the same high school in Tuckerman, Arkansas and were known to each other, though Sydney had recently unfriended him on Facebook prior to her disappearance.
According to statements Lewellyn later gave to Arkansas State Police investigators, he was driving in the area when he spotted Sydney jogging. He turned his truck around after passing her and said he could no longer see her when he came back, which he attributed to dust from the gravel road. He stated he believed he had struck her with his truck and that she was dead. He then took her body to a rice field, dug a hole, removed her clothing, and, according to his own words, "tried messing with her a bit." His attorneys instructed him not to elaborate further when investigators pressed him.
Sydney's body was found on August 21, 2020, buried in a makeshift grave in a rice field in Jackson County. DNA testing confirmed her identity. The state medical examiner determined she died from multiple blunt force injuries and ruled the death a homicide. Lewellyn was arrested shortly after her body was discovered. Cell phone tracking data from his phone was a key factor in locating the body and identifying him.
Following his arrest, Lewellyn joined a Facebook group dedicated to finding the missing Sydney Sutherland, reportedly in an attempt to track the investigation and create an appearance of concern. He was charged with capital murder, rape, kidnapping, and abuse of a corpse. His attorneys later argued that the killing was a horrible accident and that nothing about it was intentional. Lewellyn ultimately pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole.
02
Chronology
Case Timeline
August 19, 2020 — Approximately 3:00 p.m.
Sydney Sutherland Goes for a Run and Does Not Return
Sydney Sutherland leaves for a jog on County Road 41 near Newport, Arkansas at approximately 3 p.m. She does not return. Her family reports her missing. Law enforcement begins a search of the area. Quake Lewellyn, who knew Sydney from their shared high school in Tuckerman, encounters her on the road during this time period.
August 19 to 20, 2020
Lewellyn Joins the Missing Person Facebook Group
In the period after the attack, Lewellyn joins a Facebook group organized to help locate the missing Sydney Sutherland. He uses the group to monitor the progress of the search and create the appearance of public concern. His cell phone location data places him in the relevant area at the time of the attack.
August 21, 2020
Body Discovered; Lewellyn Arrested
Sydney Sutherland's body is found buried in a makeshift grave in a rice field in Jackson County. Cell phone location data from Lewellyn's phone played a key role in locating the burial site and identifying him as a suspect. DNA testing confirms Sydney's identity. Lewellyn is arrested shortly after the discovery of her body. The state medical examiner later determines she died from multiple blunt force injuries and rules the death a homicide.
August to October 2020
Charges Filed; Lewellyn Admits to the Killing
Lewellyn is charged with capital murder, rape, kidnapping, and abuse of a corpse. He makes statements to Arkansas State Police investigators admitting he struck Sydney with his truck and subsequently took her body to the rice field. He pleads not guilty in October 2020. Prosecutors announce they will seek the death penalty if he is convicted of capital murder at trial.
November 2020
Mental Evaluation Requested
Lewellyn's attorney Bill James requests a mental health evaluation, stating it is in the best interest of his client and is not intended to delay proceedings. A criminal responsibility evaluation is conducted and becomes part of the case record.
2021 — Pre-Trial
Venue Changed to Newport; Plea Negotiations Begin
A judge rules that the case has received too much publicity to be tried fairly in Jackson County and moves proceedings to Newport in the same district. The defense argues that the killing was a horrible accident and was not intentional. Plea negotiations take place with the approval of the Sutherland family, who agreed to a plea deal that would take the death penalty off the table.
October 1, 2021
Guilty Plea and Life Sentence
Quake Lewellyn pleads guilty to capital murder and rape in a Newport courtroom, waiving his right to a jury trial. He is sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole on both counts. The courtroom is packed with supporters of the Sutherland family wearing pink, Sydney's favorite color. Victim impact statements are delivered, including a statement from Sydney's mother Maggy Sutherland. Lewellyn will never be released.
03
Law Enforcement
The Investigation
The investigation into Sydney Sutherland's disappearance began on August 19, 2020, when she was reported missing after not returning from a jog on County Road 41 near Newport. The Jackson County Sheriff's Office and Arkansas State Police led the search. The rural character of the area and the gravel road terrain shaped both the search effort and the available physical evidence.
Cell phone location data from Quake Lewellyn's phone proved central to the investigation. The data placed him in the relevant area at the time of the attack and subsequently led investigators to the rice field where Sydney's body had been buried. Her remains were found on August 21, 2020, two days after she went missing. DNA testing confirmed her identity. The state medical examiner's report established the cause of death as multiple blunt force injuries consistent with being struck by a vehicle.
Lewellyn was arrested shortly after Sydney's body was discovered. He made statements to Arkansas State Police investigators in which he admitted to striking her with his truck and then taking her body to the rice field. His explanation was that he had turned around after driving past her, could no longer see her due to road dust, and believed he had accidentally hit her. Investigators noted that he had joined the Facebook group organized to find the missing Sydney Sutherland in the period between the attack and her body's discovery, a behavior consistent with an attempt to monitor the investigation and manage his own exposure to suspicion. A criminal responsibility evaluation was later conducted at the request of his defense attorney. That report is included in the documents below.
County Road 41, Newport area, Arkansas
The case was prosecuted by John D. Pettie, the sexual assault prosecutor for the Third Judicial District. The Sutherland family approved a plea agreement that secured a life sentence without parole in exchange for Lewellyn waiving a jury trial and avoiding a death penalty proceeding. The case was moved from Jackson County to Newport after a judge ruled that pre-trial publicity had made a fair and impartial jury impossible to seat in the original venue.
Case Document
Criminal Responsibility Evaluation Report — Quake Lewellyn. Psychological evaluation conducted in connection with the capital murder and rape charges arising from the August 2020 death of Sydney Sutherland. Requested by defense counsel in November 2020 as part of pre-trial proceedings in Jackson County, Arkansas.
Download Criminal Responsibility Evaluation (PDF) ↓
04
Convicted
The Accused
Quake Lewellyn
Farmer — Jonesboro, Arkansas
Age at Time of Offense: 28
Age at Sentencing: 29
Hometown: Jonesboro, Arkansas
Relationship to Victim: Known acquaintance; attended same high school in Tuckerman, Arkansas
Marital Status at Time of Offense: Married; living with wife and three stepchildren
Charges: Capital murder, rape, kidnapping, abuse of a corpse
Plea: Guilty — Capital murder and rape (October 1, 2021)
Sentence: Life in prison without the possibility of parole
Prosecutor: John D. Pettie, Sexual Assault Prosecutor, Third Judicial District of Arkansas
Case Disposition
Quake Lewellyn pleaded guilty to capital murder and rape on October 1, 2021, waiving his right to a jury trial. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole on both counts. The plea agreement was reached with the approval of the Sutherland family, who chose to accept a guaranteed life sentence rather than pursue a death penalty trial. Prosecutors had previously stated they would seek the death penalty if a jury convicted Lewellyn of capital murder. The defense had argued the killing was a horrible accident and not intentional. Lewellyn himself had admitted to striking Sydney with his truck and burying her body. He will never be released from prison. Prosecutor John D. Pettie stated: "It is the hope of this office that the Sutherland family can now have some closure and sense of finality. No length of incarceration or no punishment available under the law will ever be sufficient to provide retribution of the evil mind that perpetrated these heinous acts."
Forensic Breakdown
Case Analysis
The Accident Defense and Its Contradictions
Lewellyn's defense position was that the killing was a horrible accident and that nothing about it was intentional. His own account to investigators, however, documents a sequence of deliberate actions following what he claimed was an accidental vehicle strike: driving to and locating her body or person, taking her to a remote location, digging a hole, removing her clothing, and sexually assaulting her. The medical examiner confirmed multiple blunt force injuries. The sequence of post-contact conduct is inconsistent with a person who believed they had caused a death by accident and was acting in panic. The deliberate nature of the burial, the removal of clothing, and the subsequent decision to join the missing person search group reflect purposeful, sequential decision-making rather than the disorganized response of an accidental encounter gone wrong.
Victim Selection and Prior Social Contact
Lewellyn and Sydney Sutherland had attended the same high school and were Facebook connections. She had recently unfriended him before her death, according to the case affidavit. The significance of the unfriending is a matter the record does not resolve definitively, but it suggests some degree of prior social tension or distance she was creating. Lewellyn was married at the time with stepchildren and was driving in the area where she regularly jogged. Whether the encounter was opportunistic or targeted has not been publicly established beyond Lewellyn's own account, which was self-serving and admitted only what the physical evidence already confirmed.
Cell Phone Evidence and Digital Tracking
Cell phone location data from Lewellyn's phone was a key factor in both locating Sydney's buried body and establishing Lewellyn's presence in the area at the relevant time. Location data from mobile devices has become a standard investigative tool in rural homicide cases where physical trace evidence may be limited and witnesses are absent. In this case it provided the geographic anchor that directed investigators to the rice field burial site. The data could not have been anticipated by Lewellyn as a form of evidence against him, and his failure to account for or disable his phone suggests he did not fully understand the forensic exposure it created.
Post-Offense Facebook Infiltration
After killing Sydney and burying her body, Lewellyn joined the community Facebook group organized to find her. This behavior is documented in a category of post-offense conduct research as investigation monitoring: an offender inserting themselves into the search or grieving process to track how close investigators are getting and to manage their own social appearance. Joining a missing person group dedicated to finding the person you have just killed and buried is a behavioral indicator of calculated concealment rather than impulsive panic, and is directly inconsistent with the "horrible accident" framing offered by his defense.
The Plea Deal and Family Agency
The Sutherland family approved the plea agreement that took the death penalty off the table in exchange for a guaranteed life sentence without parole. This decision reflects a documented pattern in capital cases where surviving families exercise agency over the sentencing trajectory, often choosing certainty of incarceration over the prolonged trauma and uncertain outcome of a capital trial. The family's choice to accept the plea ensured Lewellyn would spend the rest of his life in prison without the risk that a jury trial might produce a different outcome or that a capital sentence might be commuted or reversed on appeal over many years.
Vulnerability of Women Exercising Alone in Public
Sydney Sutherland was jogging alone on a rural gravel road in the middle of the afternoon when she was attacked. Research on lethal violence against women consistently identifies outdoor exercise in isolated or semi-isolated settings as a context in which women face elevated risk from strangers and acquaintances. The rural Arkansas road environment offered no witnesses, no bystanders, and no mechanism for immediate intervention once the attack began. Sydney's case became part of a broader national conversation about the safety of women exercising outdoors, which had been heightened in 2020 by several high-profile attacks on women runners across the United States.
In Memoriam
They Are Not Forgotten
Sydney Sutherland was 25 years old and she went for a run. That is what she did. She was a nurse. She took care of people for a living. She loved animals and books and exercising and the color pink. She went out on a Wednesday afternoon in August on a road she knew and she did not come home.
Her mother Maggy stood in a courtroom and looked at the man who killed her and said: "She was not yours to take." She said: "Satan is real. The hands you hugged me with are the same hands you killed her with." There is no way to prepare to say something like that out loud. There is no way to prepare to be in that room at all. Maggy Sutherland stood up and said what needed to be said and she said it clearly.
The town wore pink. The courtroom filled up with people who came to honor her. A scholarship was created in her name at Arkansas State University so that her presence in the world would continue to mean something and open doors for others the way she would have opened them herself.
Sydney Sutherland was a genuine spirit and a bright ray of sunshine. Her family said so and everyone who knew her agreed. She was 25 years old and she deserved the rest of her life. She is not forgotten.
Sources
KATV — "Quake Lewellyn pleads guilty to murder, rape in Sydney Sutherland case" (October 1, 2021) | THV11 — "Quake Lewellyn pleads guilty to murder, rape of Sydney Sutherland" (October 1, 2021) | Arkansas Times — "Plea deal gives life sentence to killer of Sydney Sutherland" (October 1, 2021) | KAIT8 — "Lewellyn pleads guilty in Sydney Sutherland murder" (October 1, 2021) | Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette — "Northeast Arkansas man gets life in prison, no parole for rape, murder of Sydney Sutherland" (October 2, 2021) | Oxygen.com — "Quake Lewellyn Gets Life In Prison For Sydney Sutherland Slaying" | Fox News — "Arkansas man pleads guilty to Sydney Sutherland murder, gets life in prison" (October 1, 2021) | Daily Mail — "Mom of murdered jogger Sydney Sutherland says she thinks killing was premeditated" | KLRT-TV — Sentencing coverage (October 2021) | Jackson County Sheriff's Office — Arrest affidavit
More Cases
Related Cases
The Murder of Tasia Fortune
Murder Case — Jackson, Mississippi The Murder of Tasia Fortune...
View Full CaseSerial Killer: Harvey Marcelin
Serial Killer Harvey Marcelin was convicted of murdering three women...
View Full Case